Tinubu's Regime is Authoritarian, fails Leadership and Democracy Tests
OPINION
By Muhammad Bashir
Let's begin with the concept of leadership.In his famous book, Becoming A Leader,Myles Munroe says "Leadership is ultimately measured by what it values",adding "True leadership values human life,human dignity, human equality,human rights, and human security".
In another place, Munroe says "In every area of life--government,business, religion, media, education and so forth--there are people who aspire to position of leadership and influence motivated by selfish ambitions.
They may not go to the extreme of persecution or murdering people,but their selfish ambition causes other types of human and social destruction".
Do you think the Tinubu administration, devoting,as it seems,more efforts to protect campaign posters and bill boards than to people's lives and properties,has any care for human dignity, rights and security?
That is one.In his compact book,Top Ten Ways to Be A Great Leader,Hanz Finzel interprets the second "I" in leadership as denoting "Integrity".
But given Tinubu's popular stand against removing fuel subsidy during the Jonathan administration and his campaign promises to reform electricity if elected, hanging a second tenure on its fulfilment,he has failed the integrity test to be necessarily passed by a leader, falling, of course, into the category of those "who aspire to leadership and influence motivated by selfish ambitions".
To understand this further,read this extract from the elegant book of Thomas Erikson, surrounded by liars:How to Stop Lies and Half-truths Ruining Your Life.
Erikson, exemplifying how people lie to gain control and power, states that "lying can be used to exercise control or power over others.For example,by manipulating information people can influence the perceptions, beliefs,or actions of others, thereby gaining the upper hand or an advantage in certain situations.Politicians from all camps do this constantly.Religious leaders do it.People promoting all varieties of opinion do it...In reality, genuine control can't reliably be maintained by means of deceptive behavior, as lies tend to be exposed sooner or later.
When this happens,any credibility and authority gained will be lost or undermined".
So,Tinubu manipulated information on the fiscal necessity of fuel subsidy abrogation,opposed it to score cheap popularity only to execute it upon ascension to power! What followed soon was,of course,a credibility loss! This is a woeful failure in leadership test.And we shall return to it later.
But let's take on Democracy test.
In their book, Democracy and Development,Adamals Przeworski, Michael Alvarez, Antonio Chelbub and Fernando Limingi argue that "the mere fact that elections have been held does not suffice to qualify the regime as democratic".
Therefore,granted that Tinubu won his first election as INEC officially claimed((even though elections are not the only yardstick of a democratic rule), his repressive tendencies and treatment of opposition as well manipulation of electoral matters all make Nigeria anything but a democratic state.
"If an incumbent party consolidated during its tenure a one-party rule or a non-party rule,"
Przeworski et al explain,"then the regime is considered to have been authoritarian from the moment at which the incumbent party assumed office."
In essence,the Tinubu administration has been so repressive that even opposition posters are reportedly not allowed on the major streets of Nigerian states ruled by his All progressive Congress (APC) just three months before the conduct of elections.
Again,it has demonstrably displayed every hallmark of an authoritarian government in its policy formulation and execution,in handling political dissent and in distributing national appointments since its inception.
In their facinating book, AUTHORITARIANISM: What Everyone Needs to Know, Professors Natasha Ezrow and Erica Frantz say most authoritarian regimes operate in sub-Saharan Africa, Asia, the Middle-East and North Africa, adding as of 2014, there were only four dictatorships in power outside the three regions.
They enumerate six features used by autocrats in their personalisation of power.
First is to narrow the inner circle, or those with whom the leader shares administrative power.
This was seen from Vladimir Putin in Russia, reducing them to only 20 to 30 individuals--all his allies
Second, They install loyalists in key positions of power by stacking major government institutions--primarily the courts, the security sector,the military, the civil service--with those deemed their steadfast allies.
They prioritise loyalty over competence in the process of appointment.
This was the way of Hugo Chavez in Venezuela during appointments to the Judiciary, the Central Bank and the state-owned oil industry.On the other hand,they purge key state institutions of their opponents to neutralize their influence, as Recep Erdogan did in the Turkish judicial sector, civil service and the military after the failed coup of 2016.
Third, they promote family members to powerful posts,to become reliable allies in unforeseen circumstances , even if they lack governance experience.Saddam Hussein appointed his son Qusay to lead the Revolutionary Guard, another, Uday to commandeer the Fedayeen and his cousin Barzan Abdalghaffar to head the Special Republican.Guard.
Fourth, they create a new political party or movement to weaken the established ones and to undermine those who could challenge them.
Alberto Fujimoro found the Cambio 90 in 1990 to cement his grip on power in Peru and Hugo Chavez created the Fifth Republic Movement in 1997 which later became the United Socialist Party of Venezuela and his political vehicle.
Fifth,they use bogus referendum to make decisions that hardly reflect public opinion,as Hitler did in 1934 to enhance his power.
They create a parallel security force to counter-balance the existing one as a strategy against coup-plotting.
Sixth and first have manifested in Tinubu's unilateral declaration not fuel subsidy without due consultation and preparation for eventual consequences.Similarly,the fourth is reflected in the alleged sponsorship of polarisation and leadership crises, with litigations rocking almost all the opposition parties.
For the second and third,the objective columnist,Dr Olu Fasan said( in the article "What Future for the Yoruba after Tinubu's Presidency?",The Vanguard of 22nd October 2026): "At
least 80 per cent of key economic, security and justice positions at the federal level are held by people with Yoruba-sounding names".
That is nepotism par excellence!
So let's get back to the leadership test.
As the co-authors above espouse,the goals of the masses are often diverse,but they typically center on basic needs, such as the desire for mouths to be fed,roofs to sleep under,and security.In other words,the economic concerns of the poor trump all other matters.
However,the regime's top agenda is how co-optation (of scholars and,media and traditional rulers among other public opinion leaders) or repression( of dissenting voices) would work out a smooth, unimpeded
access to a second tenure.
Co-optation and repression are the two strategies of survival in an authoritarian government.They are made necessary by the spectre of life after power, especially one spectacularly abused.
An of course, authoritarian leaders have fallen in various ways over the course of history.From 1950 to 2012, the world witnessed 473 of them,from whom 20 left power by death,65% by coups and removals,7% by armed insurgency,3 by mass uprisings and 5 % by foreign invasion.
Meanwhile,this piece was written with key parts of Kaduna metropolis and major roads coming under heavy security presence as armed policemen were deployed to man the roads and campaign boards.
Reason:the Presidential campaign train was to take off from the state, with scores of youths and women hired to grace the Presidential arrival.
That took place against the backdrop of public outrage over an alleged budget exceeding 2 trillion by a state government ever blaming inherited debt for low project execution and decrying fund scarcity.
That is approximately the combined budgets of the state for the years 20204,2025 and 2026 fiscal years! Imagine a federal and state government giving more priority to campaign materials and activities than security for human lives and public welfare!
In a nutshell, if a government pushes up living cost for the people by overtaxing them in the same of economic reforms without caring to alleviate their suffering with cushioning policies but ends up embezzling the saved resources on frivolities rather than use them judiciously for development purposes,it is abysmally failing leadership, public trust and integrity tests.
Conversely,if a regime makes lopsided appointments, confines national positions to a small elite circle or a few ethnic groups at the expense of the larger citizen population,or reserves critical projects in favour of a particular section of the country;if it imposes the ruling party on the nation,muzzles the press and castrates the opposition by overt or covert electoral means,putting partisan figures in key and strategic positions against public protest to aid its re-election agenda,it is openly failing democracy and credibility tests.
For these and other unmentioned facts,President Tinubu's government is authoritarian, failing both leadership and democracy tests in its four years of office!
Yet , according to leadership expert, Dr Myles Munroe, authoritarian power can lead to (mass) resentment, angry confrontations and(decisive) emotional outburst.
It interesting to know the extent of its preparartion to contain such eventuality.
Muhammad Bashir wrote from Kaduna.07055341872/07032259251
Email: muhammadmb2026@gmail.com, bashirsenior@yahoo.com.
No comments