Nigeria @ 66: IBB was Totally Wrong !
By Muhammad Bashir
When former military President Ibrahim Babangida was asked on the national hue and cry regarding Nigeria's under development crises in the midst of 66th anniversary Independence celebration, he replied "It is lack of patience, as some countries have been independent 200 or 300 years ago"!
However, the statement was more of a conscious falsification,than sincere representation, of reality.Pro-elite IBB was referring to the US(1776), the Dutch (1648), Belgium(1816), Brazil (1822) and other developed countries that are by no means comparable to Nigeria given their inclusive institutions.But where are Indonesia(1945 with a 5.29% gdp); Malaysia (1957/6.0%); Singapore (1965/5.0%); Rwanda (1962/10%); Kenya (1963/4.9%); Tanzania (1961/5.9%) and Botswana (1966/8.70%) today?
Before anything, what even is development?
In their book, Development and I State in the 21st Century,
Professor Natasha Ezrow, Erica Frantz and Andreal Kendall Taylor state that development entails economic,social and political transformations.
Economic developmen transcends economic growth per capita , savings and investment but also socio-economic improvements in living standard, health care, education and quality of life, which bring about more choices and opportunities.This is where it overlaps with social development.
Political development is the construction of responsible and representative governments and encouragement of mass participation together with the creation of political structures, organisations that enhance government performance.
The central theme here is change,growth, progress or an evolution of the human condition.
However,state institutions matter critically in the attainment of national development.In their seminal book,Why Nations Fail,Daron Acemoglu ba ND James Robinson attribute post-independence state failure -common in Africa-to the nature of political and economic institutions of a given country.
Institutions that are extractive promote the concentration of national resources and all economic opportunities in the hands of a few elite, discouraging individual talents, entrepreneural skills and productive efforts among the mass population, narrowing the chances of prosperity and,as currently happens in Nigeria, condemning the majority to poverty and destitution.
This is why scholars say economic growth alone is not a reliable method to measure development.But being one of the most intellectual leaders Nigeria ever had, IBB should have read the book I cited on this topic.And even though the economies mentioned are a different case altogether, Nigeria is a typically extractive state where not only economic growth
enhances elite income without making life better for the poor,but also where extracted national wealth is subject to larceny by predatory rulers.
For instance,.to buttress the argument that the richest states in natural resources are also among the poorest in the world, Prof Natasha et al cite Nigeria as one of the notable states that have proven incapable of translating their oil revenues into economic growth.According to them,"Since 1971, the state has owned 55-60% of oil operations onshore, earning about 60 billion in revenues in 2005."Yet over $400 billion in revenues have disappeared since 1970.
The authors say "oil revenues have done little to lift the country out of poverty. Its GDP per capita was a little over $1,000 in 1970;30 years later it remained at just about the same value.During the same period,Nigeria's poverty rate also more than doubled (from around 35%. to around 70%) and inequality worsened considerably.
In 1970,the top 2% of the population and the bottom 17% earned the same income,whereas by 2000 the top 2% of the population and the bottom 55% did(World Trade Organization)".
This is a quintessential case of an extractive state.And it doesn't end there.The vast oil deposit also makes Nigeria a rentier state--states that rely on reoursce revenues at the expense of developing productive capacity or even administrative institutions to generate enough tax for functional operation.The governments assume there will be steady flow of income from those resources and resort to borrowing in the event of price fluctuations or even crash,falling into a debt trap.
The lure of such resource wealth drives thier leaders to relax on building the state economy and engage instead in corrupt practices as well as holding onto power for decades- damaging the economy through kleptocratic plunder and democracy through their autocratic rule.
This has been the trouble with many Middle East states,some Latin and African countries.
In fact, Professor Paul Collier lists and explains the key anti-development factors in his famous book,The Bottom Billion:Why the Poorest Countries Are Failing and What Can Be Done About it.They are majorly the Conflict Trap,the Resource Trap,Being Landlocked with a Bad Neighbor and what he called Bad Governance in a Small Country.
I don't know If Gen. IBB rtd. has seen the video clip advert featuring his military colleague,Gen. Abdussalam Abubakar recuperating after a knee surgery at an Indian hospital as was recently circulated.Again,same General was behind admitted alongside late President Buhari at a London clinic in the final days of the latter!
This means the colonial masters-despite their sinful acts-were able to build our state(infrastructurally)even though without national identity; yet their successors could build neither the state(institutionally)nor the nation(cohesively).And is why,with due regards to IBB,I say Nigeria's crises of development is not a matter of IMPATIENCE by the suffering people of the country,it is simply a sad and regrettable function of bad governance!
Muhammad Bashir is a researcher in Kaduna.Email:
muhammadmb2026@gmail.com, bashirsenior@yahoo.com
07055341872
07032259251
No comments