Kila: Before You Cast The Stone
By Wole Olaoye
I cannot recall ever sharing the same physical space with the embattled public commentator, Anthony Kila, but my heart goes out to him in this hour of tribulation. I have only spoken to him on phone. I found him respectful, brilliant, personable, engaging and worldly-wise.
Say what you will, as a public intellectual, Kila was often perspicacious and insightful. He spoke like a man who professes something - Okot p'Bitek taught me that every professor must profess something! But for the thorough investigation done by Premium Times, it would have been difficult to pull him down from his alleged bogus academic pedestal.
Kila's spurious claims, as catalogued by Premium Times, are typically human, not exclusively Nigerian, even if universally condemnable. I urge you not to join those who see this as a golden opportunity to engage in their favourite pastime of casting stones at a fallen man. I don't believe in hitting a man when he is down. Rather, I think this is a moment to teach and learn.
*Title Mania*
First, considering our society's glorification of all manner of titles - real, fake, conjured, invented or manufactured - it was only a matter of time before an Anthony Kila emerged. If he had not happened, society would have created him. He is in the eye of the storm now simply because his number has been called.
Do you know how many other fake professors are out there milking whatever they can from assumed status until fate comes knocking in the form of another hard-nosed journalist?
Kila thrived as a 'professor' in the public eye for over a decade because he relied on self-created entities and unverified institutional credentials. His claim that his professorship - "Jean Monnet Professor of Strategy and Development" - was awarded in 2016 by the European Centre for Advanced and Professional Studies (ECAPS) was debunked when investigations found no record of ECAPS as a recognised higher education institution.
Also, the European Education and Culture Executive Agency (EACEA), which administers official Jean Monnet actions, confirmed he was never awarded a Jean Monnet Chair or Professorship.
The rudest shock was the revelation that Kila fabricated an extensive list of advanced degrees - BA, MA, MSc, MBA, LLM, PGCE and PhD - from prominent international universities. Aston University had no record of him for an MBA. The University of Essex said his postgraduate diploma in media and communication did not exist in their records. City University London reported that he did not complete his degree programme. The University of Cambridge disproved his claims of a PGCE and LLM.
The genius of Kila's alleged deception was in establishing and running the Centre for International Advanced and Professional Studies (CIAPS), through which he controlled his own bio listings, journal publications and intellectual output, projecting the image of an established academic and thought leader without undergoing traditional university peer review or tenure processes. He was his own university.
Institutions and media platforms routinely accepted his self-reported titles at face value. He looked truly believable. His public acceptability and media exposure catapulted him to being appointed pro-chancellor of Michael and Cecilia Ibru University (MCIU). That appointment has now been withdrawn.
*Jason Arday*
But wait a minute. The world witnessed the widely reported case of former University of Cambridge Sociology Professor, Jason Arday, who was found dead in London in August 2026 at age 41 following serious allegations regarding his academic credentials, backstory and significant parts of his published work.
Arday was appointed Professor of Sociology of Education at the University of Cambridge at 37, making him one of the youngest Black professors ever appointed at Cambridge. His inspirational backstory - claiming he was unable to speak until age 11 and unable to read or write until age 18 - was the stuff of enduring fables.
However, it all ended tragically. Following exposure and scrutiny of his qualifications, Arday resigned from his chair at Cambridge. Several days later, he was found dead.
No man should be pushed to the precipice where suicide looks more attractive than repentance.
*A Global Phenomenon*
Academic fraud is a global phenomenon. Across Europe and North America there have been many cases of individuals who claimed fake professorships, fabricated academic titles, or built major careers on completely fraudulent credentials.
Ward Churchill (United States/University of Colorado Boulder) rose to full tenured professor of Ethnic Studies despite having neither a PhD nor standard academic credentials required for tenure. He also claimed American Indian ancestry. He was fired in 2007.
There was the case of Karl-Theodor zu Guttenberg, Germany's Defence Minister in 2011, who claimed an elite doctorate from the University of Bayreuth. Investigations revealed major portions of his thesis were plagiarised word-for-word, leading to revocation of his PhD and his resignation.
Two years after Guttenberg's disgrace, Annette Schavan, Germany's Federal Minister of Education, had her doctoral title revoked by Heinrich Heine University Düsseldorf due to systematic plagiarism. She had to resign.
There was also the Axact Degree Mill Network. Axact operated hundreds of fake online universities - such as "Nixon University" and "Brumford University" - issuing fraudulent PhDs and professorship certificates to thousands worldwide. Numerous media commentators and private college lecturers in the US and Europe were exposed for purchasing fake credentials.
One of the saddest cases was Prof. Jan Hendrik Schön (Germany/Bell Labs, US). Considered a physics prodigy tipped for a Nobel Prize, Schön claimed groundbreaking advances in nanotechnology. But independent researchers discovered he used identical noise graphics and data plots across multiple unrelated experiments. Bell Labs fired him, and the University of Konstanz revoked his doctorate.
There are hundreds more. I mention these cases not to glamourise fraud but to show we are dealing with a worldwide phenomenon.
Society should never condone academic fraud. It is proper that credible platforms associated with Anthony Kila have dropped him.
Men and women of goodwill should now offer him a shoulder to lean on and encourage him to retrace his steps in humility like a repentant prodigal son.
However, so that the day may not come when we shall have to make the same pleadings on your own behalf, remember the wisdom of the ancestors: "Before you clean someone else's yard, sweep your own doorstep."
Jason Arday was pushed by a horde of sanctimonious judgementalists into depression and death. I plead that we treat Anthony Kila with consideration and empathy. That is what our humanity demands.
No comments