Breaking News

Atiku's Mistake on Subsidy Restoration


OPINION 

By Muhammad Bashir

Let me first set the record straight with two fundamental facts : Economic reform is often problematic as far as democracy is concerned.Again, resource-richness before democratisation reduces the motivation for democratic reform.

According to Professor Ali Mazrui, wealth which is not created but only mined produces an affluent elite of LEISURE rather than elite of LABOUR.The system which emerges is closer to a plutocracy (rule by rich)rather than democracy (rule by people).

There are examples from oil-producing countries (Nigeria, Algeria and Libya)and how resource-rich but not oil-based economic (South Africa and the Democratic Republic of the Congo).
Gaddafi's Libya was a kind of welfare state--affording medical, educational, residential and other forms of subsidies to the citizens.Saudi Arabia is a welfare state for Saudi citizens but not for the millions of foreign workers.

Nigeria's petro-wealth did not result in a welfare state to serve all Nigerians but resulted in a local oil market which was subsidized.Until recently,Nigerians would get their petrol below market-value.There were also many occasions when poor Nigerians helped themselves to oil outside the constraints of the law.The dilemma of an oil-rich developing country is between using the national resources to create a welfare state and allowing its citizens to have subsidized access to the commodity without a welfare state. 

In the case of Nigeria, subsidized oil and cheaper petroleum reduced the cost of energy locally,but without a national service or subsidized housing.Gaddafi's Libya,on the other hand,had provided elaborate welfare welfare services without necessarily subsidizing the local energy-market.

Subsidizing petroleum does help those who own cars,and promotes cheaper electricity.But it is elitist in being more selective than a full-scale welfare state.This is where the dilemma begins in Nigeria's case,so Atiku's pledge needs close examination.

For instance, official records show that while the country lost some 4 trillion to subsidy before its termination,the government has generated 15.4 trillion therefrom out of which it allotted 10.4 to state governments and the foreign exchange witnessed remarkable improvement,the Monetary Policy Rate declined from 27.5 to 26.5, inflation dropped to 22.%,GDP surged from 27.4 in 2023 to 3.89% in 2026,oil production from 1.3 to 1.56m and the nation's foreign reserve moved from $35bn to 52.73bn by July 2026.

In fact,the government faced acute spending pressure on high wages, increasing debt structure and infrastructure deficit and thus succumbed to excessive borrowing during the subsidy regime.The abrupt decision of the Tunubu administration to discard it brought a merciful intervention to all these;so Atiku's intention to return it threatens, according to many economists, to reverse the achievements and restore such fiscal and institutional crises that have been luckily eliminated.

But Atiku is right on a number of grounds---economic reforms,while needing a human face,must have direct bearing on the lives of the people.Yet almost by consensus, pundits agree that Nigerian households only read the so-called gains of the reforms on the pages of newspapers.As one commentator explained recently,there are three economies operating in Nigeria:the formal economy, which is read on official papers;the informal, comprising small and medium-scale business enterprises and the survival economy, consisting of the poor households and who constitute the majority of the national population.So while statistics show improvement in GDP performance, poverty remains high and the cost of living keeps rising for the vulnerable.What then is the use of the accrued revenue savings?
The advertised idea was that the money would be deployed to vital sectors of the economy so that effects of the ensuing hardship could be mitigated.

However, what the government ended doing was merely sporadic stations for converting CNG vehicles to subsidise mobility cost for the low- income earner among commuter population.

Yet, transport cost itself depends on a vast array of factors including road provision, mass transit, vehicle availability, logistical efficiency, agricultural productivity, storage facility, energy and security distribution.
That is why the World Bank advocated specific transfers, infrastructure investment, electricity reforms and productivity-enhancing investment.


However, what the government ended doing was merely setting up sporadic stations for converting da s-fuelled vehicles to subsidise mobility cost for the low- income earner from the commuter populations.

Yet, being just one component of the cost structure, transport depends on an array of factors, namely road provision, mass transit, vehicle availability and logistical efficiency.While fuel prices affect transport and food distribution, food prices depend on agricultural productivity, storage facility, energy , security and distribution.
That is why the World Bank advocated target intervention through specific transfers, infrastructural improvement, electricity reforms and productivity-enhancing investment.

In essence,the Tunubu administration has made stupendous savings from subsidy withdrawal,and has allocated huge amounts to state governments,who have however failed to lift the people out of overflooding currents of poverty and misery.And this is one problem of economic reform amid institutional failure.In her seminal book, development and the State in the 21st Century,Professor Natasha Ezrow argues that economic gains may be distributed unequally or even be squandered by -corrupt-government officials.

In other words, reforms need institutional capacity to yield desired outcomes.And this is where we must be careful with Atiku's promise to return subsidy.

Another thing is consensus-building and public participation before a reform succeeds.Public exclusion denies a state the vital information, public trust and co-operation it needs for a policy to deliver result.So put shortly,if Buhari like Jonathan faied to protect subsidy from un-Godly opportunists in the past and Tunubu could not shield the savings from its removal from squander in the present, what plan has --he--Atiku at hand against the illi cit trend when he comes to power? Or is he merely making a cheap political promise to garner the votes of the people?


Muhammad Bashir is a researching commentator writing from Kaduna.
muhammadmb2026@gmail.com/bashirsenior@yahoo.com 
07055341872

No comments